Listed below is the players who have played first class cricket for Otago. Of these the players prior to 1890 played for the Oamaru Cricket Club who when playing outside matches would take the best players from opposition clubs to create an 'un-official' North Otago Representative side.

Not included on this list is the following players who played first class cricket with links to playing junior cricket in North Otago but did not play for the North Otago Senior Representative team and/or Otago.
Dennis Blundell (played for Wellington), Zin Harris (New Zealand, Canterbury) and Ben Harris (Canterbury, Otago)

Of those who have played for Otago Arthur Fisher, John Reid and David Sewell would also play for New Zealand, with both Sewell and Reid playing test matches. Sewell has played the most for Otago while the current Otago squad includes Warren McSkimming, Craig Smith and Shaun Haig.

Note: matches indicate how many matches they played for Otago not how many first class matches they played in total over their careers. Thanks to Warren Shirley providing the names and the number of matches played by each player. The number of matches played is correct as of the 17th of September 2009.